Title
Resolution - Approval of Rate Changes - R Kruger
Other Info
Submitted By: Randy Kruger
Department: Finance
Financial Impact and Cost/Benefit Considerations: Financial impact of the proposed rate changes is as described herein.
Discussion
1. Base Power Charge
• Flat Base Power Charge
The Tariff and Business Rules of the Cooperative (the “Tariff”) currently include a Base Power Charge, which recovers the power purchase costs and other costs incurred in connection with the development and management of the Cooperative’s power supply to serve the membership’s electric energy requirements.
The Base Power Charge attributable to power purchase costs is largely driven by energy and ancillary service costs in the ERCOT market as well as the ERCOT market performance of the generation portfolio of the Lower Colorado River Authority, the Cooperative’s primary power supplier. Given the Cooperative’s forecasted expense for power, a decrease of $0.008000/kWh to the amount of the Base Power Charge is recommended to manage the over/under collected balance for power supply.
|
Charges: |
Current Amount: |
Proposed Amount: |
|
Flat Base Power Charge |
$ 0.065900 |
$ 0.057900 |
The decrease in revenue from the recommended adjustment to the Flat Base Power Charge is forecast to be approximately $59.5M in 2027.
• Time of Use Base (“TOU”) Power Charge
Additionally, a change to the current TOU Base Power Charge is necessary to more accurately reflect expected pricing patterns in the wholesale market for certain seasons and time periods and is expected to be revenue neutral.
Current Time-of-Use Base Power Charge
|
Season |
Time of Use Period |
Proposed Charge per kWh |
|
Summer (Jun-Sep.) |
Off-Peak |
12:01AM - 2:00PM; 9:01PM - 12:00AM |
$0.043481 |
|
|
Mid-Peak |
2:01PM - 4:00PM; 8:01PM - 9:00PM |
$0.093169 |
|
|
Peak |
4:01PM - 8:00PM |
$0.161843 |
|
Shoulder (All Other Mos.) |
Off-Peak |
12:01AM - 5:00PM; 9:01PM - 12:00AM |
$0.043481 |
|
|
Mid-Peak |
5:01PM - 9:00PM |
$0.086442 |
|
Winter (Dec.-Feb.) |
Off-Peak |
12:01AM - 5:00AM; 9:01AM - 5:00PM; 9:01PM - 12:00AM |
$0.043481 |
|
|
Mid-Peak |
5:01AM - 9:00AM; 5:01PM - 9:00PM |
$0.086442 |
Proposed Time-of-Use Base Power Charge
|
Season |
Time of Use Period |
Charge per kWh |
|
Summer (Jun-Sep) |
Off-Peak |
12:01 AM - 2:00 PM; 11:01 PM - 12:00 AM |
0.042888 |
|
|
Mid-Peak |
2:01 PM - 6:00 PM; 10:01 PM - 11:00 PM |
0.075837 |
|
|
Peak |
6:01 PM - 10:00 PM |
0.099774 |
|
Shoulder (All Other Months) |
Off-Peak |
8:01 AM - 3:00 PM |
0.029139 |
|
|
Mid-Peak |
12:01 AM - 8:00 AM; 3:01 PM - 5:00 PM; 10:01 PM - 12:00 AM |
0.040533 |
|
|
Peak |
5:01 PM - 10:00 PM |
0.079678 |
|
Winter (Dec-Feb) |
Off-Peak |
10:01 AM - 5:00 PM |
0.031686 |
|
|
Mid-Peak |
12:01 AM - 5:00 AM; 8:01 AM - 10:00 AM; 9:01 PM - 12:00 AM |
0.064441 |
|
|
Peak |
5:01 AM - 8:00 AM; 5:01 PM - 9:00 PM |
0.089028 |
With changes to the Flat Base Power Charge and the TOU Base Power Charge, the net impact on most residential members will be a decrease of approximately $10.00 per month for a member that uses 1,250 kWh per month. This will be a 6.0% decrease to the average member’s monthly bill.
These adjustments to the Flat Base Power Charge and the Time-Of-Use Base Power Charge will go into effect on March 1, 2027.
2. Distribution Charge
Currently, distribution cost is being partly recovered from the Delivery Charge, which applies a rate to the total kWh delivered during a billing period. This charge applies to residential and small power members. An adjustment is necessary to more accurately allocate distribution costs, both within and between rate classes.
It is proposed to implement a Distribution Charge, replacing the current Delivery Charge. This charge, per kWh, will be measured as the greater of kWh delivered or received within the billing period and will be applicable according to the member’s rate schedule.
Rates associated with this charge will be adjusted to be revenue neutral.
This Distribution Charge will go into effect March 1, 2027.
3. Demand Ratchet
PEC recovers its cost associated with providing distribution service through the Capacity Demand Charge and Peak Capacity Charge. These charges are applied to the maximum demand of power delivered or received during a fifteen (15) minute interval within the billing period. Consistent with PEC’s Rate Policy, several rate design objectives have been considered in reviewing these charges. For example, rate stability is a concern because demand charges can be highly variable for members whose peak demand fluctuates between billing cycles. Also, achieving equitable rates can be a challenge because cross-subsidies arise within a rate class when fluctuating charges result in certain members paying less than their share of cost and others whose demand does not fluctuate paying more. Upon review, an adjustment is necessary to more accurately allocate distribution costs within rate classes and provide better rate stability.
It is proposed for all Large Power and Industrial rate classes to implement an 80% ratchet with an 11-month lookback period (greater of current month, or 80% of the maximum over the previous 11 months).
Rates associated with this charge will be adjusted to be revenue neutral.
This Demand Rachet will go into effect March 1, 2027.
4. Interconnect Rates
Last year, the TOU Interconnect Rate was made available to members with distributed generation. Members with distributed generation were given the option to choose the TOU Interconnect Rate or the Sustainable Power Credit. Credits were made applicable to offset energy charges, with any unused credits rolling over monthly and expiring at year end.
2026 marked the first time since its inception that the Sustainable Power Credit decreased. Because of market fundamentals and the hourly profile of production from distributed solar resources, the Sustainable Power Credit is expected to continue declining into the future.
Because the Sustainable Power Credit uses a three-year historical average, the credit now results in a subsidy between PEC members due to the recent rapid decline in market prices.
a) It is proposed to discontinue the Sustainable Power Credit and move all members from the Sustainable Power Credit to the TOU Interconnect Rate on March 1, 2027.
b) Additionally, as a transition plan for existing and future unused credits, it is proposed to issue a one-time payment of any unused credit balances as of March 1, 2027. It is further proposed that effective March 1, 2027, credits will be applied against the entire bill and a 12-month rolling expiration of any unused credits will be implemented.
This proposed adjustment will address potential over/under recovery between member groups and is expected to have an overall impact in 2027 of approximately $200,000 in expense for the Cooperative.
5. Distribution Rates
The PEC Rate Policy requires PEC to conduct a Cost-of-Service Study (COSS) at least every three years. Consistent with the PEC Rate Policy, a COSS was performed in 2026. This study evaluated the revenue requirement for PEC member classes, and these member class level costs were utilized in the development of rates.
The recommended rates presented below coincide with the billing units proposed in items 2 and 3, above, which address the Distribution Charge and Demand Ratchet.
|
|
Residential |
Residential Interconnect |
Small Power |
Small Power 3-Phase |
Small Power Interconnect |
Large Power |
Industrial |
|
Current Rate |
0.022546 |
0.022546 |
0.007849 |
0.026506 |
0.007849 |
6.74 |
0.49 |
|
Proposed Rate |
0.023649 |
0.015117 |
0.007849 |
0.024475 |
0.017670 |
7.34 |
2.43 |
It is proposed to implement these adjusted rates to recover distribution revenue requirements. This proposed adjustment will address potential over/under recovery between member classes.
6. Discretionary Service Charges
As part of the COSS, PEC evaluates each of its discretionary service charges. At a minimum, this involves a refresh of resource costs, which will typically cause only incremental changes in fee levels. Such is the case for the Open Records Fee and Subpoena Response Service Fees shown on the first two rows of the table below.
Additional consideration was given to the AMI Opt-Out Program and easement release reviews. The AMI Opt-Out Program currently reads every meter every month. It is proposed to modify this protocol to enact quarterly reads with estimated billing all other months. This will result in cost savings and a flat monthly fee of $40. As the AMI Opt-Out Program is closed to new applicants, it is recommended to delete those associated fees. Further refinement of the easement release review processes recognized that these reviews are often much more involved. To address this incremental cost, it is proposed to implement a separate fee for more advanced reviews.
|
FEE |
CURRENT AMOUNT |
RECOMMENDED AMOUNT |
|
Open Records Fee - Staff research time |
$ 70.00 per hour |
$ 80.00 per hour |
|
Subpoena Response Service Fee |
$ 70.00 per hour |
$ 80.00 per hour |
|
Advanced Metering Opt-Out Program - Nonpayment Disconnect/Reconnect Fee |
$ 200.00 per meter |
DELETED |
|
Advanced Metering Opt-Out Program - Meter Exchange Fee |
$ 200.00 per meter |
DELETED |
|
Advanced Metering Opt-Out Program - Meter Reading and Processing Fees |
$ 30.00 monthly processing fee per meter and $3.50/mile meter reading trip charge per premises |
$ 40.00 monthly processing fee per meter |
|
Easement Release Review Fee (Basic) |
$ 100.00 |
$ 100.00 |
|
Easement Release Review Fee (Advanced) |
N/A |
$ 400.00 or actual cost, whichever is greater |
|
Easement Obstruction Review Fee |
$ 775.00 or actual cost, whichever is greater |
$ 825.00 or actual cost, whichever is greater |
Body
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE COOPERATIVE that the rates and corresponding effective dates as described herein are approved with such changes, if any, as were discussed and approved by the Board on this day; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Cooperative is directed to incorporate such rate changes into its Tariff and Business Rules as of the effective date described herein; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Chief Executive Officer, or designee, is authorized to take all such actions as needed to implement this resolution.